2nd Prize 2015 Sentient Student Essay Competition
Refining pain relief during lamb castration and tail-docking
By Holly Pickett
Explores increasing welfare concerns about less-than-ideal pain relief being given to young lambs (Ovis aries) during basic husbandry procedures.
A number of painful procedures are generally performed on lambs without pain relief, including mulesing, tail-docking, castration, ear-marking and ear-tagging (EFSA, 2014; Melches et al., 2007; Molony et al., 2011; Rutherford, 2002). Techniques involved and use of analgesics are considerably affected by labour and economic constraints (Stewart et al., 2014), which have significant impacts on the welfare of the animals involved (Molony et al., 2002). Of particular concern are young animals (Guesgen, 2011; Bateson, 1991). Behaviour assessment and cortisol levels of lambs, kids and calves suggest that castration stress is greatest in lambs (Mellor, 1991). “Stress” results when an individual experiences acute, chronic or long-term disruption in homeostasis (Edwards et al., 2011), but historically the idea of animals feeling pain was grossly underestimated or dismissed (Anand & Craig, 1996). Change in this aspect of animal welfare requires scientific innovation, a change in cultural values and a willingness to address economical, technological and regulatory constraints (Weary et al., 2006). This is an innovation that should be grasped by Veterinarians. As respected professionals in the industry, animal welfare and welfare improvement, should be on the fore front of the agenda.
A number of studies have researched the effects of different drug types and modes of administration to relieve pain in lambs (Mellor et al., 2008; Paull et al., 2009) during such husbandry procedures as tail docking and castration. Although studies have shown the benefits of using local analgesics (Mellor & Stafford, 2000; Lomax et al., 2010), it is still common practice to perform husbandry procedures without them (Stewart et al., 2014).
Stewart et al. (2014) have investigated some “farmer friendly” forms of pain relief. The study investigated the effectiveness of pain relief for 4-week-old lambs with lignocaine-coated rubber rings (RR) for castration. Effectiveness was measured by both behavioural and physiological responses to the different treatments (Stewart et al., 2014). Lambs (n=60) were randomly assigned to one of six treatments: handling exposure but without castration (C); castration with a standard RR (R); castration with a Lignocaine-coated ring (RLA); local anesthetic (LA-lignocaine) injected into testes and scrotal neck 4 minutes before the normal RR application (LADR); local anesthetic injected directly before normal RR application (LAIR); and injection of LA, no castration (LA). These techniques were somewhat similar to those performed by Mellor & Murray (1989) and Paull et al. (2009). Behavioural changes such as abnormal lying (e.g., lying with legs extended), abnormal activit y (e.g., kick(s), backward walking or stomping) or postural changes (standing/lying) were one measure of response (Stewart et al., 2014; Molony et al., 2002). The other measure was physiological response, measured by plasma cortisol concentrations as described by Fisher et al. (2002) and Moloney et al. (2002).
Overall, the study found that lignocaine-coated elastrator rings offer practical pain relief for castration in lambs (Stewart et al., 2014). The LA and RR reduced pain-associated behaviours and circulating cortisol concentrations to a significant degree compared to normal RR and is practical, time-efficient and cost-effective. However, at this stage it is not effective enough to meet optimal pain-relief standards (LADR) because diffusion through the skin from the rings was not rapid enough and further research is needed (Stewart et al., 2014).
A recent study by Small et al. (2014) offered another alternative mode of pain relief for lambs at marking, via oral Meloxicam. Compared to the study by Stewart et al. (2014), husbandry techniques differed – knife castration and hot-iron tail-docking were tested rather than RR castration. Immediately before the procedure, pain relief was administered orally. Responses to the procedure improved with the pain relief administered. As in Stewart et al.’s (2014) study, this was measured by time taken to mother up afterwards and observed behavioural responses to the different treatments. In addition, measurements of weight change and wound scores were also taken 4-7 days post marking. The results were striking: Meloxicam-treated lambs showed no effect on mothering up and had a 7-fold reduction (p<0.001) (Small et al., 2014) in abnormal behaviours (the same behaviours as measured by Stewart et al. (2014)). Meloxicam-treated lambs spent more time displaying normal beha viours on the day of marking, and slight benefits were also visible 24 hours after administration. Overall, this mode of pain relief appears to have provided better analgesia to lambs on the day of marking compared to Stewart et al.’s (2014) LA RR. However, in comparison, it does require additional handling and cost. Further research into these methods would be of great benefit.
While pain relief via analgesics is gold standard, there are also management strategies that may minimise pain responses in lambs during husbandry procedures (Guesgen, 2011). Sheep are herd animals and social context can modify behaviours and affect behavioural and physiological responses to stress. Presence of conspecifics and their physiological state can rapidly affect an individual’s response to stimuli (in a positive or negative way) (Colditz et al., 2012). Furthermore, social buffering is also a result of the relationships among the individuals involved and previous experience in the current environment (Guesgen et al., 2014). Social buffering, such as among siblings, can result in opiod release and hence has an analgesic effect (Kikusui et al., 2006; Ligout & Porter, 2004; Porter et al., 1995) in stressful situations. Information such as this also suggests that welfare can be enhanced via management.
Suffering is in no way acceptable for any species. Findings by Clark et al. (2014) suggest that long-term effects may be seen in animals that had pain inflicted as neonates. As such, variations in management of lambs in early life may result in some long-term and even trans-generational effects on individuals. Clark et al. (2014) found that individuals (n=7) exposed to tail-docking without pain relief or suffering mild infection as neonates (the result of husbandry procedures), displayed higher levels of pain during labour. Furthermore, those individuals with lowered pain thresholds were found to give birth to lambs with lower pain thresholds (Clark et al., 2014).
In conclusion, long-term effects of husbandry procedures, such as tail-docking and castration, can have long-term adverse effects on commercially important species. As such, variation in herd health and pain management has particularly important implications for animal health and welfare (Clark et al., 2014).
It is the role of veterinarians to assess and pertain pertinent information in this field and help appropriate industry personnel understand the relevance and importance. As professionals in the industry, veterinarians are key figures in distributing education on better animal welfare practices. Veterinarians have the ability to translate current research into it's practical application. Hence veterinarians have the ability to utilise their position in society to offer a far better standard of animal welfare, guided by current scientific research.
Anand, K.J.S., Craig, K.D. 1996 New Perspectives on the definition of pain. Pain, 67, 3-6.
Bateson, P. 1991 Assessment of pain in animals. Animal Behavior, 42, 827-839.
Clark, C., Murrell, J., Fernyhough. M., O’Rourke, T., Mendl, M. 2014 Long-term and trans-generational effects of neonatal experience on sheep behavior. Biological letters, 10:7, 1-4.
Colditz, I.G., Paul, D.R., Lee, C. 2012 Social transmission of physiological and behavioural responses to castration in suckling Merino lambs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 136:2-4, 136-145.
Edwards, L.E., Arnold, N.A., Butler, K.L., Hemsworth, P.H. 2011 Acute effects of mulesing and alternative procedures to mulesing on lamb behavior. Applied Animal Behavior Science, 133, 169-174.
EFSA Panel on Animal Health and Welfare (AHAW) 2014 Scientific opinion on the welfare risks related to the farming of sheep for wool, meat and milk production. EFSA Journal, 12:12, 33-39.
Fisher, A.D., Verkerk, G.A., Morrow, C.J., Mathews, L.R. 2002 The effects of feed restriction and lying deprivation on pituitary-adrenal axis regulation in lactating cows. Livestock Production Science, 73, 255-263.
Guesgen, M.J., Beausoleil, N.J., Minot, E.O., Stewart, M., Jones, G., Stafford, K.J. 2011 The effects of age and sex on pain and sensitivity in young lambs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 135, 51-56.
Guesgen, M.J., Beausoleil, N.J., Minot, E.O., Stewart, M., Stafford, K.J. 2014 Social context and other factors influence the behavioural expression of pain by lambs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 159, 41-49.
Kikusui, T., Winslow, T.J., Mori, Y., 2006 Social buffering: relief from stress and anxiety. Philosophical Transactions of The Royal Society B, 361, 2215-2228.
Ligout, S. Porter, R.H. 2004 The role of visual cues in Lamb’s discrimination between individual age mates Behaviour,141 617-632.
Lomax, S., Dickson, H., Sheil, M., Windsor, P.A. 2010 Topical anaesthesia alleviates short-term pain on castration and tail docking in lambs. Australian Veterinary Journal, 88:3, 67-74.
Melches, S., Mellema, S.C., Doherr, M.G., Wechsler, B., Steiner, A. 2007 Castration of lambs: A welfare comparison of different castration techniques in lambs over 10 weeks of age. The Veterinary Journal, 173, 554-563.
Mellor, D.J. 1991 Effects of castration on behavior and plasma cortisol concentrations in young lambs, kids and calves. Research in Veterinary Science, 51, 149-154.
Mellor, D.J., Murray, L. 1989 Effects of tail docking and castration on behaviour and plasma cortisol concentrations in young lambs. Research in Veterinary Science, 46:3, 387-391.
Mellor, D.J., Stafford, K.J. 2000 Acute castration and/or tailing distress and its alleviation in lambs. New Zealand Veterinary Journal, 48, 33-43.
Mellor, D.J., Stafford, K.J., Todd, S.E., Lowe, T.E., Gregory, N.G., Bruce, R.A., Ward, R.N. 2008 A comparison of catecholamine and cortisol responses of young lambs and calves to painful husbandry procedures. Australian Veterinary Journal, 80:4, 228-233.
Molony, V., Kent, J.E., McKendrick, I.J. 2002 Validation of a method for assessment of an acute pain in lambs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 76, 215-238.
Molony, V., Kent, J.E., Vinuela-Fernandez, I., Anderson, C., Dwyer, C.M. 2011 Pain in lambs castrated at 2 days using novel smaller and tighter rubber rings without and with local anaesthetic. The Veterinary Journal, 193, 81-86.
Paull, D.R., Lee, C., Colditz, I.G., Fisher, A.D. 2009 Effects of a topical anaesthetic formulation and systemic carprofen, given singly or in combination, on the cortisol and behavioural responses of Merino lambs to castration. Australian Veterinary Journal, 87, 230-237.
Porter, R.H., Nowak, R., Orgeur, P., 1995 Influence of a conspecific agemate on distress bleating in lambs. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 45, 239-244.
Rutherford, K.M.D. 2002 Assessing Pain in Animals. Animal Welfare, 11, 31-53.
Small, A.H., Belson, S., Holm, M., Colditz, I.G. 2014 Efficacy of a buccal Meloxicam formulation for pain relief in Merino lambs undergoing knife castration and tail docking in a randomised field trial. Australian Veterinary Journal, 92:10, 381-388.
Stewart, M., Beausoleil, N.J., Johnson, C.B., Webster, J.R., Shutz, K.E., Cox, N., Stafford, K.J. 2014 Do rubber rings coated with lignocaine reduce the pain associated with ring castration of lambs? Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 160, 56-63.
Weary, D.M., Niel, L., Flower, F.C., Fraser, D. 2006 Identifying and preventing pain in animals. Applied Animal Behaviour Science, 100, 64-76.